Reply to Dr. Tahir-ul-Qadri on Achi BID’AT & Buri BID’AT ki Tareef (By Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza)

ye shaqk aik number ka jahil aarmi hey isey ilm e deen ka fahm bilkul nhi hey khali kitabi malumaat hey totey ki tarah rat rakhi hey chizey aur haditho sey apney mutabik ka ghalat mafhoom nikalta hey…aur logo ki zehn sazi krney mey mahir bhi hey….iskey iss bayan sey khud ba khud biddat ki sahi aur ghalat aksaam saabit ho rahi hey…aur ye uskey radd mey baatey bana raha hey..kitni ajeeb baat heyna….allah aesey fool logo sey hamari hifazat farmaye….ameen

صرف بس منٹ لکچر دینے سے ہوگیا وہ اچھی بدعت جس کو سنت ہوجاتا ہے صرف آپکے کہنے سے ہو جاتا ہے

Asslamualaikum Bhai aap ne ek latifa sunaya zo haqikat hai. Phir aap ne Shaikh ul Islam Dr Mohammad tahir ul qadri ka zirk kiya ki "…………………." aap ne phir apni zahalat dikhty huai Kaha"….." Phir aap ne iss bayan ko zaher alod baat kahi.
Me aap ko baatado ki 3th sawal ka zawab bahoot aasan hai. Aur wo hai darood . qki darood k bigair namaz nahi hoti .ab bataoo koan fasa. Aur yeh bohat asan tha. Aur darood sent karna sirf o sirf Allah ki hi sunnat hai . insan o zin aur fasity tuo sirf Allah se dua karte hai ki " ay Allah darood bhej Mohammad per"
Aur zaha tak bidat ka sawal hai us per aap ka view suna khud hi hadiths ko interpret karte ho aur baaty badi badi. Aap ne iss puri bahes me aap ne bas yeh kiya ki bidat hasana ko sunnat e hasana bana diya aur bidat e sahiya ko sunnat e sahiya banadiya. Explain kardy ta hu ki. kaise?
Tuo suno Bhai mriza

Dekhiye har niya kaam (umor e madasahat) zo nabi k wisal k baad huai wo bidat hai (ager koi naya kaam nabi k hayat e zahiri me hoa tuo wo bidat nahi yeh alag bahes hai kiya ho naya kaam ( umor e mosadahat ) sariyat me wo farz hai ya wazib ya sunanat e mokida ya gair mokida ya mustahaib ya mubah. Yisi tarah nahih me haram ya makroor etc aur yeh bhi k nabi ne kaise us umor e modasahat ko address kiya takid ki ya targaib di ya khamos rahe etc iss bahaes me nahi jana topic nahi hai.
Bidat wo umor e modahat hai zo nabi k wafat k baad hui.
Ab zara gaoor se sune ki bidat hone k liye compulsory hai k wo umor e modasat (naya kaam) ho.zaisa k sari hadiths me "zisne deen me naya kaam kiya aur wo deen me se na ho tuo wo bidat hai (tuo wo mardood hai) yisi tarah sab hadiths me nabi ne naya kaam aur bidat ko ek sath Bayaan kiya. Mirza Bhai ne achche umore modasahat ko sunnat e hasna me dal diya aur bure umore modasahat ko sunnat e sahiya me dal diya haq baat kahoo tuo sunnat e sahiya ko bidat banadiya. Iss tarah bidat hasna ko delete kar diya.
Aur ya sab hoaa iss wazai se k Mirza Bhai ne logvi (meaning) meaning in language aur istalavi (definition) meaning in subject ka fark khatam karky bure topic me naya fitna daldiya.

Darasal zo Mirza bhi sunnat e hasana karrahe hai wo sunnat logvi maana me hai achcha tarika rasam o riwaj na ki istalvi maana me hai istalavi maana me sunnat ka maana nabi k tor o tarika hai aadat e mubaraka hai. Aur sariyat me ye farz aur wazib k baad aataa hai
Aur bidat ka logvi maana kuch aur hai aur istalavi maana kuch aur.
Sunnate hasna ki zitni misale Mirza Bhai ne di wo sab bidat e hasna ki istila me aate hai Bhai me "zisne deen me koi naya kaam (umor e modasahat) aur wo deen me Nahi" iss hadiths se buniyad rakhi aur sunnat e hasna o sahiya wali hadiths tak legaye aur logvi aur istalavi maana ka fark mita kar ek mafroza ghad kar kaam ilm logo ko gomrah kiya aur iss bahes me naya fitna dala.
Sayad itna kafi wo samajne k liye.
Bhaion me ne sirf iss video k uper point out kiya hai bidat k topic per Nahi kaha ager badat per likhta tuo insha Allah andaz kuch aur hota
Ek suggestion hai ilm hasil kare aise logo k naye nàye fitne se bache. Asslamualaikum

Allah aap ko salamat rakhe aur deen aur duniya dono jagha kamiyabi ata farmaye …Ameen ya Rabbal Alameen

mashallah ali bhai allah apko ajar dey

Ap ki is definition ki roo say to darood o salam ki asal Quran se sabit hay…. aur Quran ka har hukm farz hay…..

ab koi akela parey
mil ke paren
bath k parey
ya adban khara ho k parey ap ko koi masala???????

jese Quran pak ka parhna sabit hay…..

ab hum akeley bhi partey hen
mil k bhi partey hen…
kharey ho k bhi partey hen
beth k bhi partey hen….
dil men bhi parhtey hen….
oonchi awaz men bhi parhatey hen…. AUR kisi nasibi ko koi masla naheen hay…..

LAKEN darood o salam parhaney pa masla hay…. yahan tak k Roza-e-Mubarik pa bhi parhen to Shirk! Shirk! Shirk! Shirk! Shirk! ki awazen aati henn…..

pata chala bat bidat ki naheen …. GAL KOI AUR HAY ??????????????????

very impressive great research

MashaAllah very nice lecture

brother engineer i love u for the sake of allah