Reply to Maulana ISHAQ r.a on Khatam-e-Nabuwwat ﷺ ??? SOFIs Vs Qadiyani Issue ??? Engr. Muhammad Ali

Ref. No. 1 : Reply to Dr. Ashraf Asif Jalali on "Kashaf & Ilham" Vs Khatam-e-Nabuwwat ﷺ ! ! Engineer Muhammad Ali : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EO5_MuMju9M

Ref. No. 2 : Reply to Mufti Muneeb-ur-Rahman حفظہ اللہ on " MO'JZAT and KARAMAT " ! ! Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rxgpLKiubJY

Ref. No. 3 : Reply to Maulana Ilyas Qadri حفظہ اللہ on "NABI ﷺ ka Khawab mein Deedar" ! By Engineer Muhammad Ali : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rxgpLKiubJY

Ref. No. 4 : QADIYANION ko Dawat-e-ISLAH ??? Khatam-e-NUBOWWAT ﷺ peh Best BOOK ??? Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f0vbZxr0vF0

Ref. No. 5 : QADIYANI kewn ISLAM qubool NAHIN ker letay ??? A Big TRUTH Revealed By Engineer Muhammad Ali Mirza ! : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPHxD0U_2KI

Great molna Eshaq SB late great

Love From India 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Firke Block ⚔️
Engr Sahab Rock 🔥😍

Allah is plumber k fitny sy sab ko.mehfooz rakhy …..

Well ali bhai ki bat me kuch assumptions h.

Inky nazdeek kashf jsi koi chez ni h is liye inki rai ye h..

Lkn molana ishaq r.h ny is mamly ko kisi or tarhan hal kiya h or jo log kashf ko manty hn unky liye molana ka jawab hi appropriate h..

Orr ye bat kashf hota h yan ni ye bht lamba topic h or dono tarf dalail hn…

Molana ishaq r.h jesa aalim koi ni h. Allah un ky darajat buland kry..

Ap nay galat baat ki muhammad ali sahab mainay khud moulana ko sona hai …. Uno nay yeh kaha kay mishain main sath dain gay

سبحان الله
الحمدلله الله اكبر

Ye wahabi kyun ap dushman banchuke hai ye Sab log direct Hadith parte hai ap kitrah.

There is another incident of Hazrat Ali which is as follows:

وأخرج ابن الأنباري في المصاحف عن أبي عبد الرحمن السلمي قال: كنت اقرىء الحسن والحسين، فمر بي علي بن أبي طالب رضي الله عنه وأنا اقرئهما فقال لي: اقرئهما وخاتم النبيين بفتح التاء

Abu Abdur Rahman narrates that he used to teach Hazrat Hasan and Hussain. Once Hazrat Ali bin Abu Talib passed nearby him while he was teaching them, so he said to him “Teach them Khataman Nabiyeen with a fatha on the ta” (Durr-e-Manthoor, Under 33,40)

Now firstly, we already have proof from the Holy Prophet saw and his wife, the mother of the believers, that Prophethood is indeed open but only to a prophet from within the ummah.

Hazrat Abu Abdullah Muhammad Bin Ali Hussain Al Hakim Al Tirmidhi states:

يقول الصوفي المعروف محمد بن علي الحسن الحكيم الترمذي (المتوفى عام 308 هـ):

“فإن الذي عَمِيَ عن خبرِ هذا يظنّ أن خاتم النبيين تأويله أنه آخرهم مبعثا. فأي منقبة في هذا؟ وأي علم في هذا؟ هذا تأويل البُلْهِ الجَهَلة.”

(كتاب ختم الأولياء، ص341 المطبعة

“According to us, it means that prophethood manifested itself in its full and complete manner in the Holy Prophet, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him . His heart became a vessel for the complete perfection of prophethood an d then hisheart was sealed. How can the glory and superiority of Muhammad, peace and blessings of Allah be upon him, be manifested if we claim that he was the last to appear in the world. This is, no doubt, an interpretation of the foolish and the ignorant.” (Kitab Khatamul Auliya, Page 341)

Al Imam Ibn Qutaybah ad-Dinwari who passed away in 267 After Hijri stated:

ويورد الإمام ابن قتيبة – رحمه الله – قول عائشة رضي الله عنها، ويعلق عليه ويقول:

“وليس هذا من قولها ناقضا لقول النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم: لا نبي بعدي، لأنه أراد لا نبي بعدي ينسخ ما جئت به.”

(كتاب تأويل مختلف الأحاديث ص127 دار الكتاب العربي بيروت)

“So far as it concerns the statement of ‘Ā’ishah ra: ‘Call the Apostle of Allāh (saw): The Seal of the Prophets and do not say: There will be no prophet after him’; it is directed to the descent of ‘Īsā asand this statement of her does not contradict the statement of the Prophet saw

‘There will be no prophet after me’, because he meant: ‘There will be not prophet after me who will abrogate that with which I came.” (Dar al-Kitaab Al Arabi, Beirut)

Furthermore, a famous scholar named Shaykh Muhammad Tahir stated:

ويقول الإمام محمد طاهر (المتوفى عام 986 هـ) أحد الصلحاء المعروفين، في شرح قول السيدة عائشة رضي الله عنها:

“هذا ناظر إلى نـزول عيسى، وهذا أيضا لا ينافي حديث “لا نبي بعدي”، لأنه أراد لا نبي ينسخ شرعه.”

(تكملة مجمع بحار الأنوار، لمحمد طاهر الغجراتي، ص 502)

“And it is narrated from ‘Ā’ishah: ‘Say that he is the Seal of the Prophets and do not say: There will be no prophet after him’. This aims at the decent ‘Īsā, and this also does not contradict the ḥadīth‘There will be no prophet after me’, because he meant that no prophet will abrogate his sharī‘ah.” (Takmilah Majmaʻ biḥār al-anwār fī gharāʼib at-tanzīl wa-laṭāʼif al-akhbār)

Even in the Sharh of Mishkat al Masabih it is written:

وقال شارح “مشكاة المصابيح” محمد بن رسول الحسيني البرزنجي: “ورد “لا نبي بعدي” ومعناه عند العلماء أنه لا يحدث بعده نبي بشرع ينسخ شرعه.”

(الإشاعة لأشراط الساعة ص149 دار الكتب العلمية بيروت)

This is also telling us that La nabiyya badi refers to a prophet abrogating the shariah of the Holy Prophet saw.

Hazrat Imam Mulla Ali Qari states:

ومع هذا لو عاش إبراهيم وصار نبيا، وكذا لو صار عمر نبيا لكانا من أتباعه عليه الصلاة والسلام كعيسى والخضر وإلياس عليهم السلام. فلا يناقض قولَه تعالى: (وخاتم النبيين) إذ المعنى أنه لا يأتي نبي بعده ينسخ ملته ولم يكن من أمته.” (الأسرار المرفوعة في الأخبار الموضوعة لملا علي القاري ص192 دار الكتب العلمية بيروت)

“Had Ibrahim lived and become a prophet, and likewise had Umar become a prophet they would be follower prophets of the Holy Prophet , peace and blesings of Allah be upon him, like Isa, Khizar and Ilyas upon whom all be peace. It does not contradict the divine word ‘KhatamunNabiyyeen’ which means that there shall not be a prophet abrogating his law nor one who was not of his followers. (Al Asrar al Marfuah fil Akhbr al Mauzuah Page 192)

Hazrat Imam Jalal-ud-Din Suyuti states referring to the Advent of the latter day Messiah and his Prophethood:

حقا كفر ته نبو بسلب قال من

“Whoever says He Will not be a prophet, he has committed disbelief” (Hijajul Karamah Page 431)

He also states that despite the latter day messiah would be a khalifa of the Ummah of Muhammadsaw, he shall remain a Messenger and a respected Prophet (Hijajul Karamah Page 426)

Alhamdolillah Proud to be the student of Ali Bhai

Ishaq Ahle hadith nahi h…
Aur Ali mirza dajjal h kazzab h

Ali bhai I joined a watsapp group of students of Maulana Ishaq and they seemed Munkireen-e-Hadees to me, when I tried to discuss it with them they just abruptly kicked me out of their group..

Please Debate Ahle Hadees Best Scholars

Molana ishaq sahib ki BAAT men wzn ha

Assalamo alaikum,janabe Eng.Saheb ki bate bahot damdar hoti lekin bat ballence ki nahi bat yeh hae ki Maulana Ishaq saheb ka agar aqida Khatami Nabuvat per aisa hae to fhir voh sharai giraft ke baher nahi,air ap khud ko bhi sambhae ,ham dil se kahte ki ap bahot achcha kam mashaallah karrahe hae,Lekin kuch andaza bayan me takabbur jhalakne lagta hae usse ehtiyat fermae.

16 October 2022….💚
155, 121 views…..💜
2.07M subscribers…..💙

NABI pak s.a.w.w or ahly baiet a.s py lakhon darood o salaam…..💚🌟🌹❣

Allah pak ali bhai ko jazay khaer or lambi umar day…amieen…..🤲🌹❣

Great great scholar ali bhai…..👍🌹❣